diff --git a/proposal/myrmidon/src/xdocs/classloader.xml b/proposal/myrmidon/src/xdocs/classloader.xml index 5a9d74205..1d81cdd39 100644 --- a/proposal/myrmidon/src/xdocs/classloader.xml +++ b/proposal/myrmidon/src/xdocs/classloader.xml @@ -1,113 +1,136 @@ - - On ClassLoaders in Ant2 - Peter Donald - - - - -
- -

In many ways Ant2 needs to follow rules similar to a number of -different application servers with respect to ClassLoader management. -Ant2 will create a number of different ClassLoaders that have access -to different sets of resources (and thus Classes). The main reason -for this arrangment is to partition different sections of the -application such as the Container, the Task API, task/type libraries -and support libraries.

- -

The recomended structure for ClassLoader relationships is a hierarchy. -When a ClassLoader is asked for a resource (or a class) it first delegates -to it's parent to ask for the resource. If the resource is not present in -its parent ClassLoader then the ClassLoader attempts to locate the resource -in it's own store. In practice this means that all the classes (and static -variables defined by said classes) in a parent ClassLoader are shared with -the child ClassLoaders.

- -

Using kooky ascii art, the specific ClassLoader structure for Ant2 is as -follows:

- - - Bootstrap - | - System - | - Common - / \ - Container Shared - / \ - Antlib1 Antlib2 ... - - - - -
- - + + On ClassLoaders in Ant2 + Peter Donald + + + + +
+ +

In many ways Ant2 needs to follow rules similar to a number of + different application servers with respect to ClassLoader management. + Ant2 will create a number of different ClassLoaders that have access + to different sets of resources (and thus Classes). The main reason + for this arrangment is to partition different sections of the + application such as the Container, the Task API, task/type libraries + and support libraries.

+ +

The recomended structure for ClassLoader relationships is a hierarchy. + When a ClassLoader is asked for a resource (or a class) it first delegates + to it's parent to ask for the resource. If the resource is not present in + its parent ClassLoader then the ClassLoader attempts to locate the resource + in it's own store. In practice this means that all the classes (and static + variables defined by said classes) in a parent ClassLoader are shared with + the child ClassLoaders.

+ +

Using kooky ascii art, the specific ClassLoader structure for Ant2 is as + follows:

+ + + Bootstrap + | + System + | + Common + / \ + Container Shared + / \ + Antlib1 Antlib2 ... + + + + +
+ +
diff --git a/proposal/myrmidon/src/xdocs/librarys.xml b/proposal/myrmidon/src/xdocs/librarys.xml index 15983fef3..96afc056d 100644 --- a/proposal/myrmidon/src/xdocs/librarys.xml +++ b/proposal/myrmidon/src/xdocs/librarys.xml @@ -1,168 +1,187 @@ - - On Librarys in Ant2 - Peter Donald - - - - -
- -

Long ago there was identified the need for librarys that contain -tasks and other elements present in the build file. This document -attempts to describe the mechanism via which these libraries will be -defined and used in Ant2. The librarys (also referred to as -deployments) will be termed antlibs.

- -

Ant librarys can be packaged and signed into a ANt Type Library -format (.atl) using the standard Java Archive tools. (For details on -the .jar file format see the - -Jar Specification.

- -

When packaged into such a form the META-INF/ directory contains -ant specific descriptors in addition to the standard Jar manifest -and other descriptor files. The archive will also contain the -.class files for all the tasks and other types the -library defines. It may also contain additional resources that can -be referenced in the build file (an example being DTDs).

- -

The library may also need access to other librarys or resources -to perform its job. For instance, if the task loaded an XML document -and then processed said document using the Trax API then -the Ant library needs to have access to the Trax API and an -implementation of the API. The Antlib mechanism thus uses the standard -"Optional Package" Specification to declare dependencies on other -libraries.

- -

The libraries will usually be installed in standard locations that -make it possible for the Ant container to automatically locate and scan -the libraries. It will also be possible for the users to specify -additional search locations or even the specific location of ant -libraries.

- -

The following sections will describe each of these different facets -in greater detail.

- - - -

FIXME: Import this part from other doco

- -
- - - -

The class and resources files should be stored as in standard jars. The -root directory being the base via which code and resources are loaded. So -the .class file for the Java class com.biz.tasks.Mytask -would be stored in /com/biz/tasks/Mytask.class

- -
- - - -

It is often the case that a library will need external resources. The -example given above described dependence on an external XML library. The -ant library thus needs a mechanism via which to declare dependencies on -external libraries.

- -

Ant2 uses the "Optional Package" mechanism. Prior to JDK1.3, an "Optional -Package" was known as an Extension. The specification for this -mechanism is available in the JDK1.3 documentation in the directory -$JDK_HOME/docs/guide/extensions/versioning.html. Alternatively -it is available online at - -http://java.sun.com/j2se/1.3/docs/guide/extensions/versioning.html.

- -

This mechanism was adopted as it is an established standard. The standard -is also begining to be adopted by other specifications such as the Servlet -2.3 API. Thus we are likely to see an increase of jars using this mechanism -to specify dependencies.

- -

The "Optional Package" mechanism allows jars to specify dependencies on other -jars that implement a particular specification at particular version levels. For -example you could specify a dependency on the Trax 1.1 API by adding the following -to the manifest of your jar.

- - -Extension-List: trax -trax-Extension-Name: Java API for XML Parsing -trax-Specification-Version: 1.1 - - -

In some cases you may also wish to specify a dependency on a specific vendors -implementation. For instance you may need to use xalan due to it implementing a -particular extension you need. In that case you manifest may contain;

- - -Extension-List: trax -trax-Extension-Name: Java API for XML Parsing -trax-Specification-Version: 1.1 -trax-Implementation-Title: org.apache.xalan.xslt -trax-Implementation-Version: 2.1.0 -trax-Implementation-Vendor: Apache Software Foundation - - -

In many cases there will be no distinction between the specification and -the implementation of a library. For instance the Velocity project only has -one implementation and one specification. In which case it is sufficient to -just declare a dependency on the Velocity "Specification". A library that uses -both the Trax API and the Velocity project may look like;

- - -Extension-List: trax velocity -velocity-Extension-Name: org.apache.velocity -velocity-Specification-Version: 1.0 -trax-Extension-Name: Java API for XML Parsing -trax-Specification-Version: 1.1 -trax-Implementation-Title: org.apache.xalan.xslt -trax-Implementation-Version: 2.1.0 -trax-Implementation-Vendor: Apache Software Foundation - - -

To make other jars available to Ant librarys as "Optional Packages" -or Extensions then you need to add a few lines to the manifest of the -other jar. The minimal manifest is the following;

- - -Extension-Name: org.realityforge.dve -Specification-Vendor: Peter Donald -Specification-Version: 1.0 - - -

It is important to note that looking for dependencies is recursive. For example, -if the ant library depends upon jar A and and A depends on B then both A and B will -need to be loaded by the container.

- -
- - - -

So far there has been no mention of implementation strategies for -managing ClassLoaders and other details about where the "Optional Packages" -are stored. This section will outline such details but they could change -in the future. The above specification will still be accurate but the approach -to implementing specification will be different.

- -

In the current architecture all of the "Optional Packages" are assumed to -be stored in the $ANT_HOME/ext directory. The runtime will scan -this directory for jars and add all the "optional Packages" found into a -registry. This registry will be used by the library loading mechanism to locate -all the "Optional Packages". The user is able to specify an alternative directory -or add a new directory to search on the commandline.

- -

When the container attempts to load an ant library it will also try to load -any needed dependencies. First it will check the parent ClassLoaders to see if any -of them contain the required dependencies. If not then it will search the -"Optional Packages" registry. If the dependency is not found then a error will be -signaled. If the dependency is found in the "Optional Packages" registry then it is -loaded by the same ClassLoader that is used to load the Ant library.

- -
- -
- - + + On Librarys in Ant2 + Peter Donald + + + + +
+ +

Long ago there was identified the need for librarys that contain + tasks and other elements present in the build file. This document + attempts to describe the mechanism via which these libraries will be + defined and used in Ant2. The librarys (also referred to as + deployments) will be termed antlibs.

+ +

Ant librarys can be packaged and signed into a ANt Type Library + format (.atl) using the standard Java Archive tools. (For details on + the .jar file format see the + + + Jar Specification. +

+ +

When packaged into such a form the META-INF/ directory contains + ant specific descriptors in addition to the standard Jar manifest + and other descriptor files. The archive will also contain the + + .class files for all the tasks and other types the + library defines. It may also contain additional resources that can + be referenced in the build file (an example being DTDs). +

+ +

The library may also need access to other librarys or resources + to perform its job. For instance, if the task loaded an XML document + and then processed said document using the + Trax API then + the Ant library needs to have access to the + Trax API and an + implementation of the API. The Antlib mechanism thus uses the standard + "Optional Package" Specification to declare dependencies on other + libraries. +

+ +

The libraries will usually be installed in standard locations that + make it possible for the Ant container to automatically locate and scan + the libraries. It will also be possible for the users to specify + additional search locations or even the specific location of ant + libraries.

+ +

The following sections will describe each of these different facets + in greater detail.

+ + + +

FIXME: Import this part from other doco

+ +
+ + + +

The class and resources files should be stored as in standard jars. The + root directory being the base via which code and resources are loaded. So + the + .class file for the Java class + com.biz.tasks.Mytask + would be stored in + /com/biz/tasks/Mytask.class +

+ +
+ + + +

It is often the case that a library will need external resources. The + example given above described dependence on an external XML library. The + ant library thus needs a mechanism via which to declare dependencies on + external libraries.

+ +

Ant2 uses the "Optional Package" mechanism. Prior to JDK1.3, an "Optional + Package" was known as an + Extension. The specification for this + mechanism is available in the JDK1.3 documentation in the directory + + $JDK_HOME/docs/guide/extensions/versioning.html. Alternatively + it is available online at + + + http://java.sun.com/j2se/1.3/docs/guide/extensions/versioning.html. +

+ +

This mechanism was adopted as it is an established standard. The standard + is also begining to be adopted by other specifications such as the + Servlet + 2.3 API. Thus we are likely to see an increase of jars using this mechanism + to specify dependencies. +

+ +

The "Optional Package" mechanism allows jars to specify dependencies on other + jars that implement a particular specification at particular version levels. For + example you could specify a dependency on the Trax 1.1 API by adding the following + to the manifest of your jar.

+ + + Extension-List: trax + trax-Extension-Name: Java API for XML Parsing + trax-Specification-Version: 1.1 + + +

In some cases you may also wish to specify a dependency on a specific vendors + implementation. For instance you may need to use xalan due to it implementing a + particular extension you need. In that case you manifest may contain;

+ + + Extension-List: trax + trax-Extension-Name: Java API for XML Parsing + trax-Specification-Version: 1.1 + trax-Implementation-Title: org.apache.xalan.xslt + trax-Implementation-Version: 2.1.0 + trax-Implementation-Vendor: Apache Software Foundation + + +

In many cases there will be no distinction between the specification and + the implementation of a library. For instance the Velocity project only has + one implementation and one specification. In which case it is sufficient to + just declare a dependency on the Velocity "Specification". A library that uses + both the Trax API and the Velocity project may look like;

+ + + Extension-List: trax velocity + velocity-Extension-Name: org.apache.velocity + velocity-Specification-Version: 1.0 + trax-Extension-Name: Java API for XML Parsing + trax-Specification-Version: 1.1 + trax-Implementation-Title: org.apache.xalan.xslt + trax-Implementation-Version: 2.1.0 + trax-Implementation-Vendor: Apache Software Foundation + + +

To make other jars available to Ant librarys as "Optional Packages" + or Extensions then you need to add a few lines to the manifest of the + other jar. The minimal manifest is the following;

+ + + Extension-Name: org.realityforge.dve + Specification-Vendor: Peter Donald + Specification-Version: 1.0 + + +

It is important to note that looking for dependencies is recursive. For example, + if the ant library depends upon jar A and and A depends on B then both A and B will + need to be loaded by the container.

+ +
+ + + +

So far there has been no mention of implementation strategies for + managing ClassLoaders and other details about where the "Optional Packages" + are stored. This section will outline such details but they could change + in the future. The above specification will still be accurate but the approach + to implementing specification will be different.

+ +

In the current architecture all of the "Optional Packages" are assumed to + be stored in the + $ANT_HOME/ext directory. The runtime will scan + this directory for jars and add all the "optional Packages" found into a + registry. This registry will be used by the library loading mechanism to locate + all the "Optional Packages". The user is able to specify an alternative directory + or add a new directory to search on the commandline. +

+ +

When the container attempts to load an ant library it will also try to load + any needed dependencies. First it will check the parent ClassLoaders to see if any + of them contain the required dependencies. If not then it will search the + "Optional Packages" registry. If the dependency is not found then a error will be + signaled. If the dependency is found in the "Optional Packages" registry then it is + loaded by the same ClassLoader that is used to load the Ant library.

+ +
+ +
+ +