diff --git a/mindspore/numpy/array_ops.py b/mindspore/numpy/array_ops.py
index 05765da243..939ddbc2b6 100644
--- a/mindspore/numpy/array_ops.py
+++ b/mindspore/numpy/array_ops.py
@@ -497,8 +497,6 @@ def column_stack(tup):
         return tup
     if not _check_is_list(tup) and not _check_is_tuple(tup):
         _raise_type_error("Tensor or, list or tuple of tensors are required, but got ", tup)
-    if not tup:
-        _raise_value_error("Need at least one tensor to concatenate.")
 
     trans_tup = ()
     for tensor in tup:
@@ -507,7 +505,9 @@ def column_stack(tup):
         if tensor.ndim == 1:
             tensor = F.expand_dims(tensor, 1)
         trans_tup += (tensor,)
-    return P.Concat(axis=1)(trans_tup)
+    if not trans_tup:
+        _raise_value_error("Need at least one tensor to concatenate.")
+    return P.Concat(1)(trans_tup)
 
 
 def vstack(tup):
@@ -545,15 +545,15 @@ def vstack(tup):
         return tup
     if not _check_is_list(tup) and not _check_is_tuple(tup):
         _raise_type_error("Tensor or, list or tuple of tensors are required, but got", tup)
-    if not tup:
-        _raise_value_error("Need at least one tensor to concatenate.")
 
     trans_tup = ()
     for tensor in tup:
         if tensor.ndim <= 1:
             tensor = _expand(tensor, 2, 0)
         trans_tup += (tensor,)
-    return P.Concat(axis=0)(trans_tup)
+    if not trans_tup:
+        _raise_value_error("Need at least one tensor to concatenate.")
+    return P.Concat(0)(trans_tup)
 
 
 def hstack(tup):
@@ -590,19 +590,18 @@ def hstack(tup):
     if _check_is_tensor(F.typeof(tup)):
         return tup
     if not _check_is_list(tup) and not _check_is_tuple(tup):
-        _raise_type_error(f"Tensor or, list or tuple of tensors are required, but got", tup)
-    if not tup:
-        _raise_value_error("Need at least one tensor to concatenate.")
+        _raise_type_error("Tensor or, list or tuple of tensors are required, but got", tup)
 
     tuple_of_tensor = ()
     for tensor in tup:
         if tensor.ndim < 1:
             tensor = F.expand_dims(tensor, 0)
         tuple_of_tensor += (tensor,)
-
+    if not tuple_of_tensor:
+        _raise_value_error("Need at least one tensor to concatenate.")
     if tuple_of_tensor[0].ndim <= 1:
-        return P.Concat(axis=0)(tuple_of_tensor)
-    return P.Concat(axis=1)(tuple_of_tensor)
+        return P.Concat(0)(tuple_of_tensor)
+    return P.Concat(1)(tuple_of_tensor)
 
 
 def dstack(tup):
@@ -641,8 +640,6 @@ def dstack(tup):
         return tup
     if not _check_is_list(tup) and not _check_is_tuple(tup):
         _raise_type_error("Tensor or, list or tuple of tensors are required, but got", tup)
-    if not tup:
-        _raise_value_error("Need at least one tensor to concatenate.")
 
     trans_tup = ()
     for tensor in tup:
@@ -651,7 +648,9 @@ def dstack(tup):
         if tensor.ndim == 2:
             tensor = F.expand_dims(tensor, 2)
         trans_tup += (tensor,)
-    return P.Concat(axis=2)(trans_tup)
+    if not trans_tup:
+        _raise_value_error("Need at least one tensor to concatenate.")
+    return P.Concat(2)(trans_tup)
 
 
 def where(condition, x=None, y=None):